“In Those Pictures, You Can See the Community”

In East and West Garfield Park, Chicago, we sought out residents’ archives to shed light on a neighborhood the city neglected.

ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. Sign up for Dispatches, a newsletter that spotlights wrongdoing around the country, to receive our stories in your inbox every week.

This article was produced in partnership with CatchLight, a nonprofit media organization leveraging the power of visuals to inform, connect and transform communities. The collaboration was part of the CatchLight Local Visual Desk in partnership with the Institute for Nonprofit News, the McCormick Foundation, the Kresge Foundation and PhotoWings. This initiative supports news organizations and visual storytellers working together to create and share community-based visual journalism. Sign up for CatchLight’s newsletter to learn more about this collaborative model for local visual journalism.

In cities across the country, some neighborhoods still wear the scars of civil unrest. On Chicago’s West Side, the vacant lots and hollow buildings that mar the streets are often attributed to the fiery upheaval following the 1968 assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. But the West Side’s economic decline was driven by much more than the riots sparked by King’s death. A 2020 ProPublica investigation showed how this downturn was caused by other factors: a long history of disinvestment, broken government promises to rebuild, widespread demolition that outpaced construction, and rampant real estate speculation by outsiders. The Madison Street commercial corridor, once one of Chicago’s busiest business districts, suffered devastating consequences, as did the surrounding East and West Garfield Park neighborhoods, working-class communities where Black Southerners had migrated.

Yet there is more to this story than misfortune. Recognizing that these neighborhoods are often viewed through the prism of what’s been lost, Chicago-based artist and CatchLight Local Chicago Fellow Samantha Cabrera Friend and the visual media organization CatchLight collaborated with ProPublica to visually commemorate those who remain and their histories. To do this, Cabrera Friend worked with residents in East and West Garfield Park to build a citizen archive, collecting, scanning and organizing photographs from their family scrapbooks, church pamphlets and household picture frames. Using a large-format film camera, she also created contemporary portraits of participants. The resulting body of images links past and present representations of multiple generations, families and communities, and offers a reflection of them that spans decades. (Watch a discussion about the process of compiling the archive.)

Archival collections act as an official record in which people can see themselves and their place in history. To make these visuals accessible to the public an exhibition titled “Meeting History: A Garfield Park Citizen Archive” is currently on view on the second floor of the Chicago Public Library’s Legler branch, in West Garfield Park, through Nov. 15. More information about the exhibition and current hours can be found here.

Below, we present excerpts from the archives of six residents.

Annette Britton
In those pictures, you can see the community. Across the street, which is now just an empty lot and where they closed up a laundromat, those both were very vibrant gas stations. One was Shell and one was Standard. And you can see it in the background of these pictures that there was a gas station there. Every household, when people have lived here [for generations], you know those things exist in the nooks and crannies, in someone’s dresser drawer, and you just don’t get to see it.”
Annette Britton’s fourth grade class photo, taken in 1968 at Dodge Elementary School
Left: A celebration held for Britton’s great-grandmother in February 1960. Right: Beulah, Britton’s great-aunt.
The backyard of Britton’s family home on Washington Boulevard
Winter in East Garfield Park

Annette Britton grew up in East Garfield Park in the 1960s, as white residents fled the neighborhood. Her family was working class, intent on saving enough money to build a new home and invest in the area.

Some of the handsome greystones in the neighborhood had fallen into disrepair. The family razed one of these dilapidated buildings on Washington Boulevard and Kedzie Avenue and poured the foundation for a new multifamily house, an effort documented in their pictures. Because it was the only home in the neighborhood anyone knew of that was built by a Black family, Britton’s childhood friends often thought they came from great means. But Britton and her siblings wore the same shoes so often that they grew holes in the bottom and her mother had to line them with cardboard.

Even after Britton left East Garfield Park for college and later for a job out of state, her connection to the neighborhood remained. She returned in 2010 to restore and preserve her childhood home, where she was photographed.

“I moved away a number of times and lived different places,” she said. “When I come back here, to my particular neighborhood, I find it is immensely beautiful.”

The foundation of Britton’s family home in 1965
A crew lays bricks on the foundation.
Britton at her family home with her grandfather’s bible on June 4, 2021

Opening photo: A view of East Garfield Park from Britton’s family home on Washington Boulevard. Archival photos provided by Annette Britton and scanned by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago. 2021 portrait by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago.

Marshall Hatch Sr. and Marshall Hatch Jr.
There’s an interesting kind of argument made, the reason why [Martin Luther] King settles on the West Side is the South Side is too tied into the power dynamic to have welcomed an outside agitator. … It made organizing easier [on the West Side]. And so he settled and organized here because people, you know, are removed from the power. And so that feeling is to this day — this feeling of being a stepchild of Black Chicago — forgotten, left out, left behind, neglected.”
Pastor Marshall Hatch Sr., center in a black button-up, and Marshall Hatch Jr., at the top of the steps in gray, with members of their congregation after Mass at New Mount Pilgrim Missionary Baptist Church on May 23, 2021

Marshall Hatch Sr. has been the pastor of New Mount Pilgrim Missionary Baptist Church in West Garfield Park since 1993. He took the job when his son, Marshall Hatch Jr., was a 5-year-old awed by the church’s high ceilings and stained glass.

“I’ve always felt like I belonged to West Garfield Park, to the church,” the younger Hatch said. As a teenager, “We’d kind of sit through church and just be thinking about, ‘Yeah, I can’t wait to go on Madison.’”

The music ministry junior choir at New Mount Pilgrim Church on Sept. 10, 1995
Hatch Sr. at a march on April 4, 2000, the anniversary of Martin Luther King Jr.’s assassination

At New Mount Pilgrim, which had been a traditional Irish Catholic parish, Hatch Sr. has installed art honoring Black American history. This includes a stained glass window entitled “Maafa Remembrance” that memorializes the middle passage on a slave ship. (“Maafa” means “disaster” in Kiswahili.)

“I did understand that as monumental early on,” Hatch Jr. said about the window, “and as a contribution to the space to make us feel like we belong.”

Today, the Hatches collaborate on the MAAFA Redemption Project, a program they co-founded at the church to support young, at-risk men of color.

“I really wouldn’t want to be a church anywhere else,” Hatch Sr. said. “This is a great place to be a church and a pastor.”

Hatch Sr.’s aid committee during Mass at New Mount Pilgrim Church on Sept. 10, 1995
Hatch Sr. celebrates his second anniversary as pastor at Mass on Sept. 10, 1995
Singers pose for a portrait for the “Voices of New Mount Pilgrim” live vinyl in the 1970s.

Opening photo: Hatch Sr., third from left holding banner, at an April 4, 2000, march. Archival photos provided by Marshall Hatch Sr. and scanned by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago. 2021 portrait by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago.

Shacarra Westbrooks
I was born in ’85. … Drugs were starting to infiltrate a little bit more at that time, but there was still some successful Black businesses thriving, and I remember being able to go to the basement stores and the garage where it was candy shops set up, being able to go to Dr. Mays, he was a Black doctor, or the dentist … or going to the barber shops right there and the beauty salons. It was all Black love and Black excellence. And I remember feeling so proud. And so inspired. It was like, ‘Oh, gosh, these people are awesome, and they’re Black like me.’”

Shacarra Westbrooks was born on the West Side. One of her first memories is of riding a tire swing at Garfield Park until she was dizzy, then being comforted by her family.

Her grandmother, a source of Deep South warmth and kindness, was the history-keeper. Like many West Siders, she arrived from Mississippi in the 1950s, when she lived through a heyday centered on Madison Street. Westbrooks experienced remnants of those times in her own childhood, but she knew them mainly through her grandmother’s stories.

“You were greeted with that warm, kind of Southern feel,” Westbrooks said. “It was the place to be.”

Shacarra Westbrooks poses for a prom picture in 2001.
Westbrooks’ grandmother Louise, second from left in background, in the late 1960s or early ’70s
Westbrooks, center in white dress, with family and friends, photographed in front of her great-grandmother's building in East Garfield Park on June 27, 2021

Today’s vacancies mix with the vibrancy of East Garfield Park in her and her family’s memories.

Now, “Madison, is like, that’s zero. When I’m driving down Madison, when I get to West Loop, I instantly feel a different change. I’m like, ‘Let me get a cup of coffee, I can stop and get something to eat.’”

But Westbrooks says there’s always hope. She owns two vacant lots with plans to make them event spaces.

Westbrooks’ cousin Corneal and his mother, Theresa, in the early 1980s
Westbrooks’ grandmother, Louise, at right in the background, with other family members in West Garfield Park in the 1970s
Inside a house in West Garfield Park, in the late 1970s or early ’80s

Opening photo: School pictures of Westbrooks’ cousin Tamika Westbrooks for the 1995-96 school year at Marshall High School in East Garfield Park. Archival photos provided by Shacarra Westbrooks and scanned by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago. 2021 portrait by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago.

Gina Jamison
I was born in the house that I was talking about, where my garden is with the structure of my family unit. And that’s why I’m back in Garfield Park because I remember that. You know, I remember when my grandmother would sit on the porch and everybody would say, ‘Hello, Miss Taylor!’ I remember that. And when I see the children coming from Willa Cather [Elementary] School, passing the guard, ‘Hello, Miss Gina!’ That’s priceless. In my childhood, I remember that.”
People tend plants during a celebration at Gina Jamison’s Kuumba Tre-Ahm Community Garden in East Garfield Park in 2014.
Jamison, far right, with family and friends at Kuumba Tre-Ahm Community Garden in 2014

Gina Jamison’s family came to East Garfield Park from North Carolina in 1947, when her grandfather purchased land in the neighborhood. She remembers getting dressed up to go shopping on Madison Street.

Her childhood home, a red brick mansion with a porch shaded by trees, housed extended family — her grandfather, parents, aunts and uncles, plus their children — and was an important first stop for more incoming relatives migrating from the South as they got settled. She cherishes the closeness of that time.

“A lot of our family have passed away,” she said. “But I really wish that people could have that experience. We never call our aunts and uncles by ‘Aunt Estelle.’ We call them by their first name. And when I hear when people do that with their families, that’s so foreign to me. That’s how close we were.”

The house was demolished in 1988. Now on that site, Jamison tends the Kuumba Tre-Ahm Community Garden, where she was photographed with multiple generations of her family.

Jamison, left in red; her daughter, far right; and granddaughters at the Kuumba Tre-Ahm Community Garden in East Garfield Park on June 2, 2021
Beds at the community garden. Pink roses had been symbolically planted in support of Jamison’s daughter, who had breast cancer.
Jamison, far left
Jamison in her garden

Opening photo: Jamison’s family home in East Garfield Park in July 1983. Archival photos provided by Gina Jamison and scanned by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago. 2021 portrait by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago.

Levette Haynes
It is one of my most important things to do — document our activities, our decision-making, our meetings because people don’t realize that is what makes history. And if we don’t do it, how will our children know what our actions were?”
Levette Haynes, left, dances with her daughter Katurah Haynes at a fundraiser for the West Side Cultural Arts Center in 2000.
The Garfield Park Fieldhouse in 1998

Levette Haynes grew up in East Garfield Park. Her early memories include a first day of school at John Calhoun North Elementary School when she and her sister played the schoolyard game Pop the Whip.

“My sister let me go, and I went flying in the air and under a car. I had scraped knees … that was not my game,” Haynes said. “Even my scars come from Garfield Park.”

She moved away, returning in 1995. In some of her pictures, she poses with her granddaughter Elisheba at a garden at the Garfield Park Conservatory and at the community market.

Haynes has contributed to an effort to restore the 184-acre park, including the fieldhouse, a bandstand, the walkways and other features. She also conducts art programs and has staged theater productions there.

Haynes holds her granddaughter Elisheba Clark at the Garfield Park community market in 2004.
Garfield Park
Haynes teaches an art class in the Garfield Park Fieldhouse.
Haynes gives a book to a student at a West Side Cultural Arts Center youth program in 2005.
Haynes, front row, kneeling third from left, with extended family, including her mother, nieces and granddaughters, near the Garfield Park Fieldhouse on June 19, 2021
Near the Garfield Park Fieldhouse in 1998

Opening photo: Haynes, left, at the Garfield Park Conservatory with her granddaughter Elisheba Clark in 2005. Archival photos provided by Levette Haynes and scanned by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago. 2021 portrait by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago.

LaShone Kelly
The reason I’m able not to give up is definitely, 100% me being able to look back at my family, and to look at photos, to look at places, to look and hear stories about them overcoming. It lets me know that my situation is not as unique as I think it is, and that somebody made it before me, so if they did it, I can do it. And that gives me strength.”
LaShone Kelly’s mother-in-law, left, with family members in Garfield Park on Sept. 24, 1948
A wedding at Metropolitan Missionary Baptist Church in 1963
Garfield Park in October 1961
Waller Apartments, a historic subsidized housing complex in East Garfield Park, in the late 1960s
The Garfield Park Conservatory in 1997

LaShone Kelly was raised in West Garfield Park. She and her husband have raised 15 children in East Garfield Park. She describes her mom, a social worker, and her dad, a computer analyst, as people who cared deeply about civil rights and struggled in professions where they faced racial discrimination.

She feels she inherited a desire to correct injustices. “There are tearful moments, fretfulness and just unbelief,” Kelly said. She finds serenity in the Garfield Park Conservatory, “a place of peace to walk through and have some solace.”

Kelly recalls East and West Garfield Park as self-contained communities where everything you needed was nearby.

“The residents of Garfield want the same things as any other community. Safe spaces, good schools, amenities, healthy food,” she said. “Most people want the same thing. The residents here are no different.”

Kelly, sitting in a chair, center-left, in white, with extended family and friends outside her home in East Garfield Park on June 5, 2021

Opening photo: A civil rights march in downtown Chicago in the late 1960s. Archival photos provided by LaShone Kelly and scanned by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago. 2021 portrait by Samantha Cabrera Friend/CatchLight Local Chicago.

About the Photographs

All participants have granted permission to CatchLight, the Chicago Public Library and ProPublica to publish and exhibit the photographs they shared from their personal collections. While scanning, Samantha Cabrera Friend documented information about each picture by asking residents to identify people or places shown and using written or produced notes on the prints themselves (such as a date). In some cases, captions indicate a general date for the time the image was made, such as the late 1960s, reflecting the source’s best recollection, and some images could not be dated. In other cases, people have not been identified when their name wasn’t known or couldn’t be recalled.

While Cabrera Friend digitized the archival images for future preservation and is providing digital copies for the archive, the physical photographs remain in the possession of the project’s participants. We express our gratitude to them for sharing their time, and their memories and stories of East and West Garfield Park.

Samantha Cabrera Friend is an artist and writer, based in Chicago.

Tony Briscoe is a reporter for ProPublica.

1980 aerial photograph courtesy of the Northeastern Illinois Planning Commission.

Max Herman, CatchLight Local Chicago, contributed research. Design and production by Jillian Kumagai, Agnes Chang and Lisa Larson-Walker.